Asmongold analyzes Starfield’s DLC struggles and their concerning implications for Elder Scrolls 6 development
The Starfield Disappointment: From Hype to Reality
When Bethesda first unveiled Starfield in 2018, the gaming community buzzed with anticipation. The prospect of exploring a Fallout-style adventure across the cosmos seemed like the ultimate gaming fantasy. However, the 2023 launch revealed significant gaps between expectation and reality that left many players underwhelmed.
While the core narrative and quest design delivered enjoyable moments, several fundamental limitations hampered the experience. The absence of ground vehicles restricted planetary exploration, spacecraft navigation felt more like fast-travel waypoints than true piloting, and excessive reliance on procedurally generated content created repetitive environments that lacked the handcrafted detail Bethesda fans expected.
These design choices represented a departure from the studio’s signature exploration-focused gameplay, leaving veteran players feeling disconnected from the immersive worlds that made previous titles like Skyrim and Fallout 4 so memorable. The disconnect between promised freedom and actual gameplay mechanics became a recurring complaint across player reviews and community discussions.
Shattered Space DLC Performance Crisis
The September release of Shattered Space, Starfield’s first major expansion, failed to revitalize player engagement as hoped. Criticism focused on the expansion’s brief storyline and limited player agency, with choices that ultimately lacked meaningful consequences—a particular disappointment for fans accustomed to Bethesda’s reputation for impactful decision-making.
Twitch personality Asmongold highlighted the alarming metrics, noting that “the brand-new expansion only added 5,000 players. That is crazy.” More concerning was his observation that “it’s actually getting outperformed by Fallout 4,” indicating that Bethesda’s eight-year-old title maintains stronger player engagement than their newest flagship release.
This performance disparity suggests deeper issues with Starfield’s long-term appeal and retention capabilities. When a studio’s previous generation title outperforms their current flagship product, it typically signals either market saturation, quality concerns, or fundamental misalignment with audience expectations—all problematic indicators for future projects.
Asmongold’s Warning for Elder Scrolls 6
Asmongold’s analysis extends beyond Starfield’s current struggles to their potential impact on The Elder Scrolls 6. “Maybe I’m crazy,” he commented, “but the fact that your new game is performing way worse than your old game, I think this is very problematic and it’s worrisome for the new Elder Scrolls game.”
The streamer’s concerns stem from observable patterns in Bethesda’s recent development approach. When a studio shifts design philosophy in ways that reduce player engagement, those changes often carry forward to subsequent projects. The transition from handcrafted worlds to procedural generation, and from player-driven exploration to more guided experiences, could significantly impact the Elder Scrolls franchise known for its rich, discoverable environments.
Asmongold explicitly stated his “expectation” for the long-awaited sequel is that it “will be bad,” though he maintains hope to be “pleasantly surprised.” This tempered pessimism reflects broader community anxiety about whether Bethesda can recapture the magic that made Skyrim a decade-defining RPG while adapting to modern gaming expectations.
Broader Implications for Bethesda’s Future
The stakes for Elder Scrolls 6 couldn’t be higher, given the monumental success of both Oblivion and Skyrim. These titles didn’t just sell well—they defined entire generations of RPG gaming and established Bethesda as masters of open-world design. The question now is whether Starfield’s reception indicates a temporary stumble or a more fundamental shift in the studio’s creative direction.
Compounding the uncertainty is the complete absence of a release timeline for Elder Scrolls 6. Without concrete dates or substantial development updates, the community is left speculating based on current patterns and recent releases. This information vacuum allows concerns like Asmongold’s to gain traction and shape public perception ahead of any official reveals.
Elder Scrolls 6 reportedly targeting 2028 release as Todd Howard shares update
Fallout 5 reportedly “fully greenlit” but with a new team making it
Is Starfield coming to PS5?
The gaming community now watches closely to see if Bethesda can address these concerns through future Starfield updates or whether the patterns established will indeed influence Elder Scrolls 6’s development trajectory. The coming months of support for Starfield may provide crucial indicators about the studio’s ability to course-correct and deliver on their legendary reputation.
No reproduction without permission：Game Guides Online » Asmongold claims Starfield Shattered Space is “worrisome” for Elder Scrolls 6 Asmongold analyzes Starfield's DLC struggles and their concerning implications for Elder Scrolls 6 development