Doom: The Dark Ages delivers exceptional combat but struggles with repetitive level design and pacing issues
Introduction: A Mixed Return to Hell
Doom: The Dark Ages presents a fascinating paradox – it delivers some of the most refined first-person combat mechanics in recent memory while simultaneously struggling with structural issues that prevent it from reaching the heights of its predecessors. This prequel to the acclaimed 2016 reboot takes players back to the medieval origins of the Doom Slayer, offering 19 hours of demon-slaying action set in a hellish medieval landscape.
The game’s combat loop stands as a genuine achievement, featuring innovative shield mechanics and bullet hell elements that transform the traditional Doom formula. However, id Software’s ambition to expand the franchise’s scope has resulted in repetitive level design, pacing problems, and underwhelming new features that detract from the core experience.
Combat Excellence: A First-Person Soulslike Revolution
The Dark Ages revolutionizes Doom’s combat by introducing a sophisticated shield and melee system that demands precision timing and strategic positioning. Unlike previous entries where aggression was the primary strategy, this installment forces players to master defensive maneuvers while maintaining offensive pressure. The shield serves as your most crucial tool, capable of blocking incoming damage and, when timed perfectly, parrying attacks to create openings for devastating counterattacks.
Combat adopts bullet hell shooter elements, requiring players to navigate through multicolored projectiles while managing close-quarters threats. This creates an experience reminiscent of first-person Soulslikes where spatial awareness and reaction timing determine success. The game slows the pace compared to Doom Eternal, encouraging tactical positioning rather than constant aerial mobility.
Pro Tip: Master the shield parry timing early – successful parries not only stagger enemies but also restore small amounts of health, creating crucial sustainability during intense encounters. Practice against lower-tier demons to build muscle memory before facing larger threats.
Weapon progression remains deeply engaging with dozens of upgrades and pinnacle challenges that encourage experimentation. The Ravager and Rocket Launcher provide reliable ranged options, but the combat truly excels during close-quarters engagements where the new one-handed weapons and shield combinations shine. This carefully balanced system creates an intoxicating flow state that remains compelling throughout the entire campaign.
Common Mistake to Avoid: Don’t neglect your mobility while focusing on shield defense. The game punishes stationary play – constantly reposition to avoid being surrounded, using your shield strategically rather than as a crutch.
Level Design: Repetitive Structure and Pacing Problems
Despite the exceptional combat, Doom: The Dark Ages stumbles with its level design structure that grows increasingly repetitive across its 22 levels. The game follows a predictable pattern: each map begins with a primary objective like activating a portal or unlocking a door, which requires completing 2-4 subsidiary tasks first. This identical framing persists throughout most of the campaign, creating a sense of déjà vu that undermines the otherwise excellent gameplay.
The expanded open areas, while visually impressive initially, suffer from pacing issues that disrupt narrative flow. Players can spend up to 45 minutes completing prerequisite tasks before advancing the main objective, during which storytelling largely grinds to a halt. The narrative progresses almost exclusively through cutscenes rather than environmental storytelling or in-game events, creating disjointed pacing that leaves players confused about their current objectives.
Optimization Tip: Use environmental landmarks to maintain orientation in large levels. The expansive maps can be disorienting – mentally note distinctive structures or terrain features to avoid retracing steps unnecessarily.
The removal of Doom Eternal’s fast-travel system exacerbates these issues. Without the ability to backtrack at level completion, players must replay entire missions to collect missed items, turning completionist pursuits into tedious chores. The soundtrack also suffers in these open spaces, with extended periods of silence replacing the constant audio intensity that defined previous entries, despite quality compositions from Finishing Move.
One notable exception occurs late in the game where environmental puzzles and disabled maps create engaging navigation challenges. This section demonstrates the creative potential largely absent from the rest of the campaign, proving that inventive level design could have elevated the entire experience.
New Features: Mech and Dragon Sections Miss the Mark
The much-hyped Atlan Mech and dragon-riding sequences represent the game’s most significant additions but ultimately feel underdeveloped. Accounting for approximately 10-15% of total gameplay, these sections provide temporary diversions from the core combat but fail to deliver the impactful experiences promised in pre-release marketing.
The mech combat suffers from peculiar scaling issues – rather than feeling like a massive mechanized warrior, the Atlan Mech gives the impression of a normal-sized character in a miniature environment. This visual disconnect undermines the intended epic scale and creates a comical rather than awe-inspiring experience. The mechanics themselves lack the depth of the on-foot combat, feeling like simplified versions rather than fully realized gameplay systems.
Dragon riding offers aerial mobility but controls awkwardly compared to the precision of standard movement. While these sections provide visual variety, they ultimately distract from what makes Doom compelling – the tight, responsive combat that defines the franchise. Fortunately, their limited presence means they don’t significantly detract from the overall experience, serving primarily as brief respites from the sometimes repetitive level structure.
Performance and Technical Considerations
Performance on base PS5 hardware reveals some technical shortcomings, particularly during the game’s more intense combat sequences. Frame rate drops become noticeable when confronting large enemy hordes, especially in the latter half of the campaign where battles grow increasingly chaotic. These performance issues occasionally disrupt the otherwise fluid combat flow, though they rarely make encounters unmanageable.
Surprisingly, the game lacks visual settings options on base PS5, preventing players from prioritizing performance over graphical fidelity. This represents a step back from Doom Eternal, which offered multiple visual modes to accommodate different performance preferences. Players seeking stable frame rates may want to consider the PC version or wait for potential performance patches addressing these issues.
Advanced Player Tip: During heavy combat scenes, focus on eliminating projectile-based enemies first to reduce particle effects and potentially improve performance. This strategy not only helps maintain frame rate but also reduces the visual clutter of bullet hell sections.
Verdict: Worthwhile for Combat Purists
Doom: The Dark Ages ultimately stands as a divisive entry in the legendary franchise. Its combat systems represent a genuine evolution, offering depth and satisfaction that rival the series’ best moments. The shield mechanics and bullet hell elements create a fresh take on the formula that will delight players seeking tactical challenges.
However, the repetitive level structure, pacing issues, and underwhelming new features prevent it from matching the consistent quality of Doom 2016 or Doom Eternal. The game feels like two different experiences – one featuring masterclass combat design, the other burdened by structural flaws.
For dedicated FPS enthusiasts and Doom series fans, The Dark Ages remains worth experiencing for its exceptional combat alone. The core gameplay loop provides enough satisfaction to overcome the design shortcomings, though players should temper expectations regarding innovation and consistency. It’s the weakest of the three modern Doom games but still delivers enough quality to justify the journey through hell.
No reproduction without permission：Game Guides Online » Doom: The Dark Ages review – Bigger doesn’t always mean better Doom: The Dark Ages delivers exceptional combat but struggles with repetitive level design and pacing issues